As latent demand for sustainable bioproducts grows, the biomanufacturing industry stands at a crossroads. Achieving commercial-scale production offers the promise of reducing per-unit costs and making bioproducts competitive with traditional manufacturing. However, the substantial investments required for scaling operations, from constructing biofoundries to optimizing strain engineering, present a formidable barrier. This conversation explores the innovative strategies and collaborative efforts needed to overcome this paradox. It highlights the pivotal role of technological advancements, standardization, and policy support in bridging the gap between the aspiration for large-scale, cost-effective biomanufacturing and the reality of high initial costs. We aim to offer a roadmap for stakeholders across the value chain to navigate this complex landscape, ultimately unlocking the potential of biomanufacturing to transform industries and contribute to a sustainable future.